Fantasy Cast for The Traitors: All-Stars

The Traitors is currently airing its fourth season on Peacock, and this show is still the best show on TV. There are a lot of rumors that the next season will be an "All-Stars" season, as calls have been going out. If so, here is who I think Peacock should cast.

The Traitors

Rob Rausch

Original Show - Love Island USA 6

Original Season - The Traitors 4

• Place: TBD (Traitor)

Rob is currently running the game on the 4th season of The Traitors. He is a traitor, and I'd love to see him eventually win the game. He definitely deserves a call back.

Natalie Anderson

Original Show - Survivor: San Juan Del Sur (Winner)

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: 7th

Natalie was just eliminated on The Traitors 4. She was on top of it but was taken out by the Olympians. Natalie deserves another chance. I'd also like to see her back on The Challenge.

Peter Weber

Original Show - The Bachelor 24 (Lead)

Original Season: The Traitors 2

• Best Finish: 8th (Faithful)

Pilot Pete was on top of the game on the 2nd season of The Traitors. He even turned down an opportunity to be a traitor from Parvati Shallow and Phaedra Parks. I'd consider making him a faithful in this reboot.

Cirie Fields

Original Show - Survivor: Panama

Original Season: The Traitors 1 (Winner)

• Best Finish: 1st Place (Traitor)

Cirie played the best winning game so far. If Rob wins this season there will be an argument, but Cirie absolutely dominated. I'd love to see how she would play again.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

FAITHFULS

Trishelle Cannatella

Original Show - The Real World: Las Vegas / The Challenge

Original Season: The Traitors 2 (WINNER)

• Place: 1ST PLACE (Faithful)

Trishelle was on top of it on the 2nd season of The Traitors. She played a great game with Dylan Efron, Bergie and more. She played under the radar and was able to get the win instead of being eliminated.

Bob The Drag Queen

Original Show - RuPaul's Drag Race 8

Original Season: The Traitors 3

• Best Finish: 15th (Traitor)

Bob The Drag Queen didn't get that far in his original season, but he did make some fireworks. His rivalry with Boston Rob was iconic, and now they host The Traitors after-show together.

Lisa Rinna

Original Show - The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Place: 13th (Traitor)

Lisa Rinna was a traitor and was banished by Rob Rausch and his group. Lisa deserves another chance. I would like to see how she would play as a faithful, though, instead of a traitor.

Christian de la Torre

Original Show - The Traitors 1

Original Season: The Traitors 1

• Original Place: 6th (Traitor)

Christian would be the only person on this season to not be a celebrity. The Traitors 1 was half celebrities/reality stars and half regular people. Christian was one of the only "regular people" that stood out to me on season 1.

Parvati Shallow

Original Show- Survivor: Micronesia

Original Season: The Traitors 2

• Place: 10th (Traitor)

Parvati is a 2-time Survivor winner, now having won Survivor: Micronesia and Australian Survivor: Australia vs. The World. She was put in a bad situation on her traitors team with Phaedra Parks and Dan Gheesling who hated each other. I would have liked to see her play with a more cohesive unit.

Dan Gheesling

Original Show - Big Brother 10

Original Season - The Traitors 2

• Place: 12th (Traitor)

Dan played too hard too quick and got caught. He deserves a 2nd shot, but they should only be willing to make him faithful.

Phaedra Parks

Original Show - The Real Housewives of Atlanta

Original Season: The Traitors 2

• Best Finish: 6th (Traitor)

Phaedra rounds out the disaster that was The Traitors on season 2. They all were good players but didn't play well together. They all deserve to come back and see how they do.

Dylan Efron

Original Show - Down to Earth w/ Zac Efron

Original Season: The Traitors 3 (WINNER)

• Best Finish: 1ST PLACE (Faithful)

Dylan Efron ran the game on The Traitors 3. He knew exactly what was happening and who the traitors were and who weren't. He ended up winning with 3 other people, but this time I'd like to see him as a Traitor.

Carolyn Wiger

Original Show - Survivor 44

Original Season: The Traitors 3

• Best Finish: 5th (Traitor)

Carolyn was a mess as a traitor. She was all over the place, and her rivalry with Danielle Reyes didn't work because they were both traitors. Carolyn would need to be faithful this season for it to be a success.

Ron Funches

Original Show - Comedian

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: 15th (Faithful)

Ron is a comedian who had the entire house against him on season 4 and still made it a few roundtables without being voted out. I'd like to see him get a fresh start on a new season.

Gabby Windey

Original Show - The Bachelorette 19 (Lead)

Original Season - The Traitors 3 (WINNER)

• Best Finish: 1ST PLACE (Faithful)

Gabby played a really good under-the-radar game and got to the end of The Traitors 3 and won. A lot of Bachelor Nation has really impressed me on this show, to be honest.

Cody Calafiore

Original Show - Big Brother 22 (Winner)

Original Season - The Traitors 1

• Best Finish: 10th (Traitor)

Cody played too hard too fast on the first season of The Traitors. He was outsmarted by Cirie Fields, who ended up winning the whole season. I'd love to see him return as a faithful.

Kate Chastain

Original Show - Below Deck

Original Season: The Traitors 1

• Place: 4th (Faithful)

Kate actually played The Traitors twice. She was on The Traitors 1 and The Traitors 2. She did better on the first season but has made it clear she had more fun on the second season. She has to be brought back.

Jeremy Collins

Original Show - Survivor: Cambodia (Winner)

Original Season: The Traitors 3

• Place: 20th (Faithful)

Jeremy deserves another chance. He was on top of the game before he was killed pretty early. He won Survivor: Cambodia and is really good friends with the next person on this list.

Sandra Diaz-Twine

Original Show - Survivor: Pearl Islands

Original Season: The Traitors 2

• Best Finish: 4th (Faithful)

Sandra knows how to play these types of games. She deserves a chance to play again since she almost won this season. Sandra would have to play with other Survivor legends on this season, like Parvati, Boston Rob, Jeremy, Natalie, and Cirie.

Johnny Weir

Original Show - Olympian

Original Season - The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: TBD

Johnny was running The Traitors 4 at one point. His game has been turned upside down due to his loyalty to Candiace Dilliard Bassett. He and Tara are now at the bottom, but I'd love to see how he adapts.

Candiace Dilliard Bassett

Original Show - The Real Housewives of Potomac

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: 11th (Traitor)

Candiace needs another opportunity. She should have tried to work with Rob and take Lisa out because they could have gotten pretty far together. I would bring her back as a faithful, though.

Tom Sandoval

Original Show - Vanderpump Rules

Original Season: The Traitors 3

• Best Finish: 4th (Faithful)

Sandoval is a mess. With that being said, I would still bring him back for an All-Stars season of The Traitors. He got pretty far on the third season. I could see him getting eliminated pretty early though.

Tara Lipinski

Original Show - Olympian

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: TBD

I went with Tara strictly because of how messy she's been recently. She is still in the game but is constantly a mess while playing. Her rivalry with Natalie Anderson is iconic too.

Chris "CT" Tamburello

Original Show - The Real World: Paris / The Challenge

Original Season: The Traitors 2 (Winner)

• Best Finish: 1st Place (Faithful)

CT played a very quiet game on The Traitors 2, but it got him to the end. He knew how to get to the end, and he won. I'd bring him back and see how he would do with a bunch of people who already know how to play.

Rachel Reilly Villegas

Original Show - Big Brother 13 (Winner)

Original Season: The Traitors 1

• Best Finish: 7th (Faithful)

Rachel is reality TV royalty who has been on 3 seasons of Big Brother and she won Big Brother 13. I want to see her rivalry with Kate Chastain again.

Michael Rapaport

Original Show - Actor and Comedian

Original Season: The Traitors 4

• Best Finish: 16th (Faithful)

Michael was a mess this season. I say bring him back to cause more chaos for the cast.