Poets logo

The Promise I Was Never Meant to Keep

A confession about resisting love — and surrendering anyway

By LUNA EDITHPublished about 9 hours ago 2 min read

I told myself I would be different.

I would not become another story

that begins with hope

and ends with silence.

I swore I would recognize the pattern —

the rehearsed affection,

the temporary warmth,

the role I always seem to play

in someone else’s unfinished film.

I said I would never again

mistake attention for intention.

Never fall for the first person

who looks at me

like I am more than background noise.

Never fall for the one

who smiles when she sees me —

not politely,

not conveniently —

but genuinely.

I promised I would not be moved

by someone who listens

without waiting for her turn to speak.

Someone who talks to me

and the conversation doesn’t feel like effort —

it flows,

like neither of us are performing.

No awkward pauses.

No forced laughter.

Just presence.

I told myself I would not be swayed

by someone who sees me

as a person —

not a favor,

not a fallback,

not a supporting character.

Someone who feels less like a risk

and more like a refuge.

Someone I can sit with

and talk about today —

not fantasy futures,

not grand plans —

just this moment.

Someone who can laugh

at the ridiculous wounds we survived

and still choose to stay.

I said I would never fall

for someone who feels safe.

Safe —

not boring.

Not predictable.

But steady.

Someone who understands

without interrogation.

Who doesn’t drag my past

into every new sunrise.

Someone who makes the morning

feel less like a burden.

I hate mornings.

But the thought of her

makes something inside me wake up

before the sun does.

Even on my worst days —

the heavy ones,

the quiet ones —

she doesn’t just brighten the room.

She shifts the gravity of my world.

She cheers for my smallest victories.

She stands still

when I feel like collapsing.

She stays.

And that is the most dangerous part.

Because I promised myself

I wouldn’t fall

for the first person

who makes me feel

seen.

I promised I would not repeat

the cycle everyone else seems

to walk into willingly.

But what is a promise

made out of fear?

What is discipline

when the heart finally feels understood?

Maybe I am not different.

Maybe I am just human.

Maybe love was never the mistake —

only the way we try to control it.

I once promised myself

I would not become

another chapter in the same old story.

But here I am —

standing at the beginning again,

wondering

if this time

it isn’t a cycle…

but a choice.

love poemsperformance poetryFree Verse

About the Creator

LUNA EDITH

Writer, storyteller, and lifelong learner. I share thoughts on life, creativity, and everything in between. Here to connect, inspire, and grow — one story at a time.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.